After checking EWG's Skin Deep 2012, I threw away all of the sunscreens and tanning lotions above. The Banana Boat Ultra Defense's overall score was a 7. The Neutrogena Wet Skin SPF30 also scored a 7. Both contained both RETINYL ACETATE (VITMIN A ACETATE) and OXYBENZONE.
The Australian Gold Sheer Coverage scored a 5 which is not bad, but mine was over a year old so I pitched it along with the others. The Australian Gold Continuous Spray SPF15 scored a 7 and contained OXYBENZONE. I was sadden to have to throw these away because I love the smell of Australian Gold but health and safety comes first!
MD MOMS Baby Silk Babysafe sunscreen towelettes scored well with a 4. The reasoning behind the higher score for this product was due to the fragrance only. We don't have any issues with the fragrance in Baby Silk products so we use these for unexpected quick trips outside. I keep the package in my purse which is very handy.
The sunscreens we found to have some of the best ratings and luckily also found in our diaper/beach bags were:
California Baby, Coopertone Water Babies Pure & Simple, and Kiss My Face Suncare products (not shown). I ordered the Kiss My Face sunscreens on Amazon.
Be sure to check out EWG's Skin Deep 2012 Sunscreen Report to make sure your sunscreens are safe for you and your family!